On this special Halloween Episode Jordan and Ashley talk about the infamous Watcher Case. In 2015 a mysterious and unknown person terrorized the Broadduses' family after they bought a house in Westfield, NJ. Sending anonymous letters with the name only "The Watcher attached". They talk about the case, some of the letters, and review the hit Netflix show called the Watcher. The pair try to separate fact from fiction and dive into their own theories. They also discuss other famous unsolved postage cases such as the Circleville letters and even the Zodiac killer.