It was late in the day on December 16, 2000, when Jerry Michael Williams failed to return home from a day of duck hunting on Lake Seminole. It was also his 6th wedding anniversary. His frantic wife Denise Williams, called the Tallahassee Florida police department to report him missing. After an exhaustive search, it was believed he fell out of his boat, and was eaten by alligators. It would take another 17 years before the truth of that night would come to light. A truth that was in fact much darker than anyone had imagined.